When students start accent modification with a native language that does not have an “R” that fits with the standard American English “R,” I set about helping the student explore their options. The standard American English “R” is difficult to nail down for many people: The tongue is ambiguously placed, and requires the right amount of tension, the right length, with the right amount of lip rounding. Absent any of these (and other) elements, the sound that beckons forth is interesting, but not quite an “R” sound. It is a sincere challenge for many non-native English speakers to acquire a Standard American “R,” but it can certainly be done. I’ve taught some students who have nailed it within five minutes; others, it’s taken a few months, with repeated reinforcement not to revert to their native curl, or throaty fricative. It is always incredibly gratifying to help a student in the “R.” And some students need to explore their options.
So there’s a choice we explore together. whether or not the standard American “R” is do-able, easy, difficult, worth it, too hard, not worth it at all. And, if it’s pretty doable, we proceed with that training. But if the student or I have a true sense, after many tries, that it’s just too hard, I support them to produce a substitute “R” in the form of a curled “R” – easy to teach, easy to pick up. Some students think the curled “R” is a speech impediment in English, but it’s really not – it’s used plenty by many perfectly articulate Americans whose native language is English. The curled “R” is easily understood as an “R,” as compared to the vague, loosely articulated attempted standard American “R.”
We do “recheck” from time to time: Is the standard American “R” accessible now, after some other training has happened? Is it absolutely necessary for professional or personal reasons to support the student to adopt a standard American “R”? If so, for either of these situations, we proceed, sometimes haltingly, with getting the standard American “R.”
Sometimes students who want accent modification lessons hesitate before that first call to me, having gotten the impression that the standard American “R” is too hard and hands-down necessary. So I encourage people to explore it as an option, but not to feel defeated if it’s just not happening or going to happen. There are always other aspects of students’ speech we can modify that ensure they will be understood all the time. There “R” options, so let’s not let that “R” get in the way.
© 2015-2018 Helen Kobek and helenkobek.com. All rights reserved.